Punjab and Haryana High Court Upholds Seniority of Employee Promoted Under Reservation, Direct Recruits Cannot Challenge

Date:


The Punjab and Haryana High Court has delivered an important ruling concerning service seniority and reservation-based promotions in Punjab. The court has clarified that an employee promoted under the reservation quota cannot lose his seniority merely because other officers were subsequently appointed to the same post through direct recruitment.

The ruling is significant for government employees as it addresses the relationship between reservation in promotions, direct recruitment and seniority rights under service rules.

The decision was delivered by a division bench comprising Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi and Justice Mindeerjit Yadav on September 30, 2026. The bench dismissed three appeals filed by the Punjab Government and other appellants, thereby upholding the earlier decision of a single-judge bench.

The case relates to Nardeep Singh, who was appointed as an Audit Inspector on October 3, 2001, under the reserved category for persons with disabilities.

He was subsequently promoted to the post of Senior Auditor on December 21, 2011, under the reservation roster system. Later, on August 17, 2016, he was promoted to the position of Audit Officer.

Meanwhile, some other officers were appointed directly as Audit Officers in December 2017. They subsequently questioned Nardeep Singh’s seniority position.

The dispute also involved certain employees who had been senior to Nardeep Singh in the Senior Auditor cadre but were promoted to the post of Audit Officer between June and August 2019. These employees claimed seniority under the catch-up rule.

The Punjab Government’s seniority list had placed Nardeep Singh below the officers appointed through direct recruitment in 2017 and certain employees promoted in 2019. Challenging this position, Nardeep Singh approached the High Court.

On January 12, 2023, a single-judge bench accepted his petition and recognised his seniority over the officers directly recruited in 2017. The state government subsequently challenged that decision through appeals.

While examining the matter, the division bench referred to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Ajit Singh Januja-II, particularly paragraph 83.

The High Court explained that senior employees who were temporarily left behind because of reservation-based accelerated promotions may claim restoration of their seniority under the catch-up rule when they are subsequently promoted to the same cadre.

However, this principle does not mean that an employee who was promoted earlier under the reservation system automatically loses seniority to officers appointed later through direct recruitment.

The court also examined the Punjab Government’s instructions dated October 10, 2014, clarifying that roster points cannot independently determine seniority. However, these instructions do not make the catch-up rule ineffective.

Ultimately, the High Court refused to interfere with the single-judge bench’s decision and dismissed all three appeals.

The ruling clarifies an important aspect of government service law in Punjab, particularly regarding the seniority of employees promoted under reservation provisions and the rights of subsequently appointed direct recruits.

The judgment is expected to have significance in similar service-related disputes involving promotion, reservation and seniority, subject to the applicable service rules and individual case circumstances.


CHANDIGARH MEDIA
CHANDIGARH MEDIAhttp://www.chandigarhmedia.com
In the wake of today's technologically driven world, people are effectively coping with the digitalized scenario. The need to spare long hours for updating oneself with whatever is happening around, has completely disappeared. An enormous hub of latest news and information is available in seconds, till the time you blink an eye, only on CHANDIGARH MEDIA. Although the internet is flooded with numerous e-newspapers, it is difinitely hard to beat CHANDIGARH HELPLINE group. You just need to join CHANDIGARH MEDIA on facebook, instagram, Youtube, Twitter or whatsapp and undoubtedly you'll be the first one with the latest news among your peers. Another positive aspect of this group is that you can also forward your promotions and become familiar among a fan base of around 30k people. So guys halt for a second and go follow CHANDIGARH MEDIA AND CHANDIGARH HELPLINE!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Vehicle in Haryana CM’s Convoy Plunges 50 Feet into Gorge in Morni Hills, Driver Among Two Injured

A major road accident was reported in Haryana's Morni...

“Claims of Being Honest, Yet Surrounded by Controversies”: Sudhanshu Trivedi Targets AAP Over Punjab PCS Recruitment Row

The political controversy surrounding the Punjab Civil Services (PCS)...

Gunmen Open Fire at Fortuner in Mohali, Mother, Son and Driver Escape Unhurt; Property Dispute Suspected

A shocking firing incident has been reported from Zirakpur...
error: Content is protected !!